I don’t like buying music online. There. I’ve said it. I don’t know if that makes me an old fart or what. I just don’t like doing it. When you buy the CD, you are actually buying something concrete… something substantial. When you buy music online, you’re buying bits.

I think my biggest problem with buying online though is that you get the music files in only one format and in only one bit rate (which you typically can’t control) and slathered chalk full of DRM. If I buy tens or hundreds of albums on iTunes, I am thereby chained to using iTunes and iTunes forever else I’ll have to rebuy all that music again. And that’s assuming that iTunes and Apple will still be around 10, 20 or 50 years from now. Those facts almost make me consider renting music. You pay a relatively small fee and can download all the music you want. But then again, if you ever stop your subscription or want to transfer your music elsewhere, you’re SOL. You never really owned anything.

However, if I own the CD, I can always rip, rip and rerip the music into any format I want. MP3 is still the dominant format nowadays, but I may want all Ogg Vorbis in a few years. No problem. I have the CD, so I can rerip it. And not just that, but CDs are already a pre-existing backup to their digital counterparts. After you rip it, the CD sits on a shelf or in a case. If your iPod or Zen or NAS dies on you, you can always just pop the CD back in and rip the songs again.

All that being said, there is one online music service that I’ve tried and may continue to use. It addresses most of my problems and I don’t feel too dirty using it:

Amazon’s music downloading service is almost everything that I’ve wanted. Look at this from their help page:

Where possible, we encode our MP3 files using variable bit rates for maximum audio quality and smaller file sizes, aiming at an average of 256 kilobits per second (kbps).

DRM-free means that the MP3 files you purchase from Amazon.com do not contain any software that will restrict your use of the file.

The albums and songs you purchase from AmazonMP3 Music Downloads are free of Digital Rights Management software so that you have the flexibility to play them on any of your media players, PC or burn them to CD.

They have high bit rate files and no DRM. NO FREAKIN DRM! No matter where I put this, it will work. It’s up to me to keep my actions legal. And I’m not a 15 year old kid that is going to share all this stuff. I actually believe in buying music and supporting the artists. If I like the stuff that the artist puts out, I have no problem giving them money so that they can continue to produce more. If my collection consists of a hundred one hit wonders, maybe I need to reevaluate my musical tastes, but that’s another blog entry…

So let’s take a look at how all this works. Let’s say you want to buy an album from Amazon. You go to the album page on Amazon as normal. Look for the amazon mp3 panel in the lower right hand side and click it if it’s available. Not all albums are available, of course, but I’ve found most of the things I’ve looked for (and my tastes aren’t too terribly mainstream):

That will bring you to the album’s purchase page in the MP3 Downloads section of Amazon. From here, you can either buy your music song by song or just buy the whole album. And a lot of songs and albums are even cheaper than iTunes:

So after purchasing the music, you than need to download Amazon’s Downloader application if you haven’t already and then the .amz token file which tells the Downloader app what to do:

The Downloader then just goes on automatically downloading your files whether in the foreground or in the background:

And when it’s done, you’re politely informed of that too:

You can then spawn off your default music player to start listening to your new purchase or you can click on “Show Downloads” to open Explorer in the folder where all your purchases are. For me, that is C:\Users\mike\Music\Amazon MP3\. They are arranged by artist then album. Pretty typical stuff. There you have all your free and clear mp3’s to do with what you want. How beautiful…

The Amazon MP3 Downloader is a pretty bare bones app. It’s not this bloated thing sitting there in your system tray taking up CPU cycles. Consequently, it doesn’t save any state. After you close it or even if you buy and download additional songs, it will have totally forgotten everything you bought beforehand. You can only access them through the file system. But that isn’t a big deal. I don’t really like it when applications try to manage that stuff for you… like iTunes. Yes, it’s yet another thing I don’t like about iTunes.

Anyway, I’ve bought three albums in researching Amazon’s MP3 service and I think I like it. I’m still a little uncomfortable that I don’t have anything concrete to show now that ten more of my hard earned dollars are gone, but I guess I need to get my head out of 1995 and embrace this new age of digital music, social networking and cloud computing.